Soda Shoppe Menu
- Cones / Soft Serve Sundaes
- Hard Ice Cream
- Sundaes
- Something Special
- Parfaits
- Syclones
- Shakes & Malts
- Floats
- Smoothies
- Kiddies Menu
- Signature Sodas / Other Drinks
Sweeties Cones
Choose from any of our homemade flavors and your choice of a cake, sugar, or waffle cone or bowl.
Size: Kiddie, Junior, Regular, and Large
Build Your Own Soft Serve Sundae
Create your own celebration of flavors by starting with chocolate, vanilla or twist custard, vanilla yogurt or our amazing flavor of the week (ask your server for details!). Choose from dozens of available toppings to finish your unique masterpiece!
Size: Small cup, Medium cup, and Large cup
* Cones available on request
Signature Flavors
Lake Erie Monster
Vanilla ice cream with brownie bits, cookie dough bites, cheesecake pieces, and dark chocolate flakes
Brookpark Buckeye
Peanut butter vanilla ice cream with miniature buckeye candies
Tommy’s Signature
Vanilla ice cream with raspberry swirl, chopped buttered almonds, and dark chocolate flakes
Bananas Foster
Banana ice cream with a caramel swirl
Other Flavors
- Vanilla
- Chocolate
- Strawberry
- Chocolate Chip
- Butter Pecan
- Superman
- Cookie Dough
- Cookie Monster
- Cherry Vanilla
- Cake Batter
- Peach
- Orange Cream
- Blueberry
- Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
- Sea Salt Caramel Toffee
- Cookies and Cream
- Parma Pistachio
- Coffee Ice Cream
- Mint Chocolate Chip
- Black Raspberry Chip
- Campfire S’Mores
- Caramel Turtle Fudge
- Black Cherry
- Pineapple Upside-Down Cake
- No Sugar Added Vanilla
- Dairy Free Vanilla
*All flavors available in quarts and pints
Classic Sundaes
Choose either a single or a double scoop and select your choice of one topping. Finished with our Sweeties Signature whipped cream and primo cherry.
Extra Toppings
Sweeties Signature Hot Fudge • Sweeties Signature Chocolate Syrup • Sweeties Signature Blend of Chopped Nuts • Sugar Free Chocolate Syrup • Caramel • Marshmallow Sauce • Spanish Peanuts • Pecans • Rainbow Sprinkles • Heath® Pieces • Butterfinger® Pieces • Butterscotch • Peanut Butter Sauce • Pineapple • Cherry Sauce • Reese’s Pieces® • Chocolate Chips • Crushed Oreo® • Reese’s Cups® • M&M’s® • Nerds®
Specialty Sundaes
Millie on a Hot Tin Roof
Vanilla ice cream, chocolate sauce and Spanish peanuts
Public Square
A chocolate chip fudge brownie, vanilla ice cream, our Sweeties Signature hot fudge, caramel sauce and walnuts
Turtle Tower
Vanilla ice cream, our Sweeties Signature hot fudge, caramel sauce, salted peanuts, garnished with a mini turtle candy
East Side West Side Splitter
A fresh banana, a scoop each of vanilla, chocolate and strawberry ice cream, topped with pineapple sauce, Sweeties Signature chocolate sauce, strawberry sauce and chopped nuts
East Side West Side Splitter (Half Size)
A fresh banana, a scoop each of vanilla, chocolate and strawberry ice cream, topped with pineapple sauce, Sweeties Signature chocolate sauce, strawberry sauce and chopped nuts
Strawberry Shoreway
A slice of buttery pound cake, strawberry ice cream, fresh sliced strawberries, and topped with strawberry sauce. cherry, Other variations available… chocolate shoreway, blueberry shoreway, and peach shoreway
Heavenly Fudge Brownie Sundae
A chocolate chip fudge brownie, one scoop each of vanilla and chocolate ice cream, topped with Sweeties Signature chocolate sauce and walnuts
Sea Salt Caramel Sundae
Sea Salt ice cream topped with warm caramel sauce, Sweeties Signature chocolate sauce and Sweeties Signature blend of chopped nuts
Peanut Butter Sundae
Vanilla ice cream, peanut butter sauce, Sweeties Signature chocolate sauce, Sweeties Signature blend of chopped nuts, chucks of chocolate
United Union of Flavors Local 6770
Vanilla ice cream topped with sliced cherry sauce, marshmallow topping, blueberry sauce and Sweeties Signature Blend of chopped nuts
Fly Me to the Moon
Vanilla ice cream, graham cracker pieces and marshmallow topping, served with Sweeties Signature Chocolate Sauce and a small moon pie.
Sweeties Cookie Sandwich
Sugar, chocolate chip, peanut butter or oatmeal raisin cookies filled with your choice of 1 scoop of ice cream. Roll in sprinkles 50¢ extra
The Cleveland Brownie
Hot fudge brownie topped with hot fudge, a scoop of vanilla ice cream sprinkled with chopped peanuts
Sweeties Sampler 5
Choose 3 flavors of ice cream, 2 toppings or 2 sauces or a combination of both!
Rock ‘n Roll Hall Rage
We top your 4 selections of ice cream scoops with strawberry sauce, Sweeties Signature hot fudge, caramel sauce, chocolate candy rocks, and a rockin’ special treat.
Sweeties Spectacular Sundae
8 scoops of ice cream with Sweeties Signature chocolate sauce, strawberry sauce, caramel sauce and marshmallow sauce. A cookie, a brownie, waffle cone pieces, Snickers and Milky Way candy bar, topped with lots of Sweeties Signature whipped cream, rainbow sprinkles, M&M’s and chocolate chips
All parfaits are served with our Sweeties Signature whipped cream and a primo cherry.
Red Velvet Parfait
Vanilla ice cream layered with red velvet cake pieces and Sweeties Signature white chocolate sauce
Triple Chocolate Parfait
Chocolate ice cream layered with chocolate crunch, Sweeties Signature chocolate sauce and Sweeties Signature blend of chopped nuts
Cookies and Cream Parfait
Cookies and cream ice cream layered with crushed cookies, Sweeties Signature chocolate sauce and a cookie on top
Apple Pie Parfait
Vanilla ice cream layered with apple pie filling, pie crust pieces and caramel sauce
Peanut Butter Parfait
Chocolate Chip ice cream, peanut butter sauce, Sweeties Signature Chocolate Sauce and Sweeties Signature Blend of chopped nuts
Strawberry Parfait
Vanilla ice cream layered with sliced strawberries and strawberry sauce
Campfire Parfait
S’more ice cream layered with graham cracker pieces, marshmallow topping and Sweeties Signature hot fudge sauce
Bananas Foster Parfait
Vanilla ice cream, sliced bananas, warm caramel sauce and pecans
Peach Pie Parfait
Peach ice cream layered with graham pieces and peach topping
Tommy’s Scribble Parfait
Tommy’s Signature ice cream layered with raspberry sauce, chopped buttered almonds, and Sweeties Signature hot fudge
Make Your Own Parfait
Choose one ice cream and up to 3 toppings
M&M’s®, Oreo®, Reese’s Pieces®, Heath Bar®, Reese’s Cups®, Nerds®, Rainbow Sprinkles, Chocolate Chips, Bananas, Strawberries, Pineapples, Cherries, Blueberries, Peanut Butter, Chopped Nuts, Pecans, or Spanish Peanuts
All syclones served with our Sweeties Signature whipped cream and a primo cherry.
Cookie Dough Syclone
Cookie dough ice cream with cookie dough pieces and Sweeties Signature chocolate sauce
Butterfinger® Syclone
Vanilla ice cream with Butterfinger pieces and Sweeties Signature chocolate sauce
Death by Chocolate Syclone
Chocolate ice cream, Sweeties Signature chocolate sauce and brownie pieces
Chocolate Cherry Syclone
Cherry vanilla ice cream, chunks of chocolate, Sweeties Signature hot fudge, and sliced cherries
Strawberry Cheesecake Syclone
Strawberry ice cream with cheesecake pieces and fresh strawberries
Birthday Cake Syclone
Cake batter ice cream, cake pieces and sprinkles
Make Your Own Syclone
Choose your ice cream flavor and 2 add ins listed below: M&M’s®, Oreo®, Reese’s Pieces®, Heath Bar®, Reese’s Cups®, Nerds®, Rainbow Sprinkles, Chocolate Chips, Bananas, Strawberries, Pineapple, Cherries, Blueberries, Peanut Butter, Chopped Nuts, Pecans, or Spanish Peanuts.
All shakes and malts served with our Sweeties Signature whipped cream and a primo cherry.
- Vanilla
- Chocolate
- Banana
- Strawberry
- Peanut Butter
- Mint Chocolate
- Sea Salt Caramel
- Peanut Butter Banana
- Orange Cream
- Cookies and Cream
- Superman
- Butter Pecan
- Downtown Malt – Our version of that famous downtown chocolate malt made many years ago
Choose from over 200 pure cane sugar soda pops
Sweeties Soda Pop Float
Select 2 scoops of ice cream and 1 bottle of soda
Sweeties Soda Pop Bottle Sampler
Your choice of 4 soda pop flavors and 4 choices of 2 scoops of ice cream served in individual glasses
Real Fruit Smoothies
- Strawberry
- Mixed Berry
- Piña Colada
- Mango
Psghetti and Meatballs
Vanilla ice cream, chocolate meatballs, strawberry marinara sauce and shredded white chocolate cheese
Let’s Play in the Dirt
Vanilla ice cream, cookie crumbs and a gummi worm
Hot Diggity Dog
A chocolate hot dog served on a cake bun with special ketchup and mustard frosting
Just Clownin’ Around
Vanilla ice cream garnished with a candy face and topped with a sugar cone
Monkey Bites
Banana dipped in chocolate with sprinkles topped with our Signature whipped cream and a cherry served along with vanilla ice cream
Signature Sodas
- Black Cherry
- Blue Raspberry
- Diet Root Beer
- Ginger Beer
- Grape Orange
- Root Beer
- Strawberry
- Vanilla Cream
- Wild Apple
Other Drinks
- 200 types of Soda Pop
- Iced Tea
- Coffee